The 2020 Canada Post Collective Agreements: A Tale of Two Tracks
The year 2020 was pivotal for labor relations at Canada Post, but the collective agreements reached that year were not a single event. Instead, they emerged through two distinct paths: a lengthy, forced arbitration for the Crown corporation’s largest unions, and a surprisingly swift, voluntary negotiation for its administrative staff. Together, these agreements shaped the working conditions for tens of thousands of employees through the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond.
The CUPW Arbitration: A Ruling, Not a Deal
For the Canadian Union of Postal Workers (CUPW), representing urban operations employees and rural and suburban mail carriers, the 2020 agreements were the product of a long and contentious process. Following rotating strikes in late 2018, the federal government appointed mediator-arbitrator Elizabeth MacPherson in December 2018 to resolve the disputes . Her ruling, issued on June 11, 2020, served as the basis for two new collective agreements, closing that round of bargaining .
The arbitrated settlement provided wage increases retroactive to 2018: 2.0% effective February 1, 2018; 2.0% effective February 1, 2019; 2.5% effective February 1, 2020; and 2.9% effective February 1, 2021 . Beyond wages, the ruling had significant operational implications. It expanded job security protections, granting a 40-kilometer relocation radius to over 6,000 additional regular employees who held positions as of June 1, 2020 . However, the arbitrator also granted Canada Post the right to leave certain vacant positions unfilled when a surplus is anticipated .
The financial impact was immediate. Canada Post reported that the new CUPW agreements added net costs of $114 million in the second quarter of 2020 alone, largely due to expanded eligibility for post-employment healthcare benefits for rural and suburban mail carriers .
The PSAC-UPCE Early Agreement: A Pandemic-Era Success
In stark contrast, the Public Service Alliance of Canada’s Union of Postal Communications Employees (PSAC-UPCE), representing roughly 2,400 administrative, technical, and financial workers, took a collaborative route. Bargaining began early, on January 27, 2020, with both parties agreeing to an expedited process focusing on a short list of issues .
Despite the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, a tentative agreement was reached on April 14, 2020, well before the previous contract expired on August 31 . Members ratified the deal in early May . The agreement, effective September 1, 2020, through August 31, 2024, provided stable, predictable increases: 2% on September 1 of each year from 2020 through 2023 . It also included improvements to parental and family obligation leave, and notably reinstated paid quarantine leave, a provision that had been removed in a previous round of bargaining .
A Contrast in Labor Relations
The dual-track outcomes of 2020 highlight the varied landscape of labor relations at Canada Post. The CUPW agreements were imposed by an arbitrator after years of friction and a government intervention, reflecting a deeply adversarial relationship. The PSAC-UPCE deal, by contrast, was reached voluntarily and ahead of schedule, even amid a global health crisis, suggesting that a more cooperative approach was possible when both parties committed to an expedited, focused process .
For the employees, the 2020 agreements delivered wage stability and, in the case of CUPW members, expanded job security protections. For Canada Post, they brought labor peace at a considerable financial cost, all while the corporation navigated the unprecedented operational challenges of the pandemic.